appmarsh | Fitbit vs Garmin: Which ecosystem is best for you?

Fitbit vs Garmin: A struggle between two health giants that is been debated for a while.

Fitbit is one of essentially the most well known health tracker corporations in the market. The emblem identify has been given the “Kleenex impact” by means of many, in that individuals consult with their health trackers as “a Fitbit” it doesn’t matter what emblem of health tracker they are if truth be told dressed in. Garmin is extra widely known for its health smartwatches that experience extra complex options for extra critical athletes.

Since we ultimate spoke in regards to the Fitbit vs Garmin debate, issues have modified. So much. The two corporations was in lots of the identical product classes and compete immediately with one some other, however that isn’t essentially the case anymore. Fitbit has necessarily cornered the low-end smartwatch and health tracker markets (no less than in the United States), whilst Garmin is a ways and away the chief within the GPS health watch area.

Oh, and Fitbit was acquired by Google originally of November, so the way forward for Fitbit’s {hardware} {hardware} and products and services is a bit of muddy. We explored some concepts in regards to the acquisition here, so take a look at our research if you are involved in finding out extra in regards to the Google-Fitbit deal.

At the moment, even though, we are evaluating Fitbit vs Garmin. Let’s get to it!

Fitbit vs Garmin: Health trackers

As mentioned, issues have modified a bit of in recent times. Fitbit remains to be freeing a couple of fitness trackers annually, whilst Garmin has slowed this a part of its product portfolio these days. Fitbit recently has four more moderen health trackers on the market on its web site. Garmin has four as neatly, however three of them are somewhat outdated.

Fitbit health trackers

  • Fitbit Charge 3 (Amazon): The Fitbit Rate 3 is the corporate’s flagship health tracker. It has lots of the identical options discovered within the Fitbit Versa and Versa 2, however in a extra compact shape issue. If you are in search of a cast health wearable and don’t need the bulkiness of a smartwatch, the Rate 3 is it.
  • Fitbit Inspire HR (Amazon): The Fitbit Encourage HR and Encourage (beneath) have taken where of the Alta collection in Fitbit’s lineup. The Encourage HR is smaller than the Rate 3 and has fewer options and a worse show, however makes up for the ones issues with a good spec sheet.
  • Fitbit Inspire (Amazon): The Fitbit Encourage is identical precise factor because the Encourage HR, simply with out the heart rate sensor.
  • Fitbit Ace 2 (Amazon): The Fitbit Ace 2 is Fitbit’s 2d kid-friendly fitness tracker. It is similar to the Fitbit Encourage, however with a tougher shape issue. It could possibly observe your kids’s process all through the day, supply bedtime signals, silent alarms, and extra.
  • What in regards to the Fitbit Zip? Fitbit hasn’t launched a real follow-up to the clip-on Zip health tracker, however there is a respectable choice. The corporate sells clip-on accessories for the Fitbit Inspire (non-HR style) that necessarily flip the gadget right into a Fitbit Zip.

Additionally learn: The most common Fitbit problems and how to fix them

Garmin health trackers

garmin vivosmart 4 review vs garmin vivosport

  • Garmin Vivosmart 4 (Amazon): The Vivosmart 4 is Garmin’s newest process tracker. It is small, has a miles stepped forward show over its predecessor, and it has a integrated pulse oximeter. Lately, Garmin rolled out connected GPS capability to it, too.
  • Garmin Vivosport (Amazon): The Garmin Vivosport is a couple of years outdated at this level, however it is the corporate’s maximum tough health tracker. It has a integrated GPS and center fee sensor, it is correct, water-resistant, and it’s pretty cheap as a result of it is been in the marketplace since 2019.
  • Garmin Vivofit 4 (Amazon): The Vivofit 4 may be a pair years outdated, however it is nonetheless a cast affordable health tracker. It has one-year battery lifestyles, an at all times on show, and it is water-resistant. We simply want it had ANT+ HR sensor improve (its predecessor did), and reasonably higher process monitoring features.
  • Garmin Vivofit Jr. 2 (Amazon): That is Garmin’s newest health tracker for youngsters. It is available in a number of a laugh designs, it is swim-friendly, has a one-year battery lifestyles, and can stay observe of your kids’s steps taken and sleep.

Comparable: The best Fitbit alternatives

What if you need one thing a bit of extra tough than the units indexed above? One thing with a larger display screen? Fortuitously each corporations have you ever coated.

Fitbit vs Garmin: Smartwatches and game watches

Fitbit remains to be quite new to the smartwatch marketplace, with simplest three units out presently. The corporate’s units are making improvements to with each and every iteration, however they are nonetheless notably behind other brands on the subject of smartwatch options.

Fitbit smartwatches and sports activities watches

fitbit versa 2 review display watch face 6

  • Fitbit Versa 2 (Amazon): The Fitbit Versa 2 is Fitbit’s 2d actual strive at a smartwatch for the loads. It is small, gentle, offers you smartphone notifications, or even has Amazon Alexa inbuilt. It is a just right health tracker too, even though sadly there is no integrated GPS.
  • Fitbit Ionic (Amazon): The Fitbit Ionic is the Fitbit smartwatch you will have to purchase if you wish to have an onboard GPS. It is a just right smartwatch and health watch, however it’s beautiful cumbersome and may not have compatibility everybody’s wrists.
  • Fitbit Versa (Amazon): The Fitbit Versa and Versa 2 don’t seem to be if truth be told all that other from one some other, so if you’ll be able to in finding this one on sale, you may need to purchase the older style. It does not have an OLED show or Alexa just like the Versa 2, however it is nonetheless an overly succesful health tracker.

Extra posts about Fitbit

Smartwatches and sports activities watches are Garmin’s bread and butter. We are going to communicate in regards to the corporate’s five primary health watch collection, however do notice that the corporate sells masses extra units on its website.

Garmin smartwatches and sports activities watches

garmin venu review watch face case on table 4

  • Garmin Venu (Amazon): The Garmin Venu is the corporate’s first AMOLED show smartwatch. It is necessarily the similar gadget because the Vivoactive 4 (beneath), simplest with a higher-resolution show and reasonably shorter battery lifestyles.
  • Garmin Vivoactive 4 and 4S (Amazon): The Garmin Vivoactive 4 is an unbelievable multisport watch. It has integrated GPS, week-long battery lifestyles, track garage and Garmin Pay, and Garmin’s new breathwork workout routines which might be if truth be told somewhat helpful.
  • Garmin Vivomove 3 and 3S (Amazon): Garmin’s hybrid smartwatch, the Vivomove, gained a large improve in 2019. The Garmin Vivomove 3 and 3S now have Garmin Pay improve, pulse oximeter sensors, and convey again the hidden presentations beneath the watch face.
  • Garmin Forerunner 245, 645, and 945 (Amazon): If you are a runner, glance no additional than the Garmin Forerunner lineup. Relying for your finances, the Forerunner 245, 645, or 945 may have one thing that fits your wishes.
  • Garmin Fenix 6 series (Amazon): There are so much of fashions within the Garmin Fenix 6 collection, so you are sure to search out one thing that fits your wishes. Those high-end multisport watches are for athletes that spend maximum in their time open air.

Extra posts about Garmin

Fitbit vs Garmin: Process and well being monitoring

garmin vivoactive 4 review vs garmin venu heart rate sensor

Regardless of which ecosystem you select, all of those units will stay observe of the fundamentals: steps taken, energy burned, and sleep. They will additionally observe your distance traveled, however simplest those with GPS (Ionic, Vivosport, and all of Garmin’s working watches) gives you correct distance metrics. The units that function integrated GPS sensors will even provide you with tempo, cadence, and elevation main points.

The Fitbit Versa and Versa 2, Rate 3, Encourage HR, Garmin Vivosmart 4, and Vivomove 3 and 3S all have connected GPS, permitting you to trace correct distance and tempo metrics in the event you deliver your telephone with you on a run. Sadly, neither the Garmin Vivofit 4 nor the Fitbit Encourage have any GPS capability.

All units indexed above will observe your overall time asleep, in addition to sleep levels, together with how steadily you spend in REM, gentle, and deep sleep, and what kind of time you are conscious all through the evening. Fitbit units gives you a 30-day reasonable of your dozing conduct (in comparison to Garmin’s seven-day reasonable), in addition to a benchmark to match in opposition to folks your age.

Additionally, if you are a Fitbit Top rate subscriber, your Fitbit gives you get entry to to dozing center fee information and restlessness. More moderen Garmin units just like the Venu, Vivoactive 4, and Vivosmart 4 all have pulse oximeters (SpO2) inbuilt, which is able to observe your blood-oxygen saturation ranges all through the day and evening. Fitbit units just like the Versa line and Ionic even have SpO2 sensors, even though this information is roped into your Sleep Ranking.

Moreover, the Garmin Venu and Vivoactive 4 units include breathing fee (or respiring fee) monitoring.

Facet notice: Garmin’s app does let you know how a lot sleep you will have to be getting in comparison to different customers, however it is tucked away within the Insights tab. It is simple to forget as a result of it is not within the Sleep segment, the place you would suppose it will have to be situated.

This is the featured image for the best workout apps for Android

If you happen to requested me a couple of years in the past which corporate has the simpler sleep trackers, I’d have replied Fitbit, arms down. That each one modified after Garmin presented complex sleep tracking in mid-2019. Now, each corporations are at more or less the similar point, give or take a couple of options.

Each ecosystems provide you with a solution to control your pressure, however each and every corporate’s way is other. Fitbit’s approach is known as Relax, and walks you via a chain of guided respiring workout routines that will help you chill out if you are too wired. Fitbit’s units use the heart rate sensor that will help you stick to alongside throughout respiring workout routines. When the workout is finished, Fitbit devices do not if truth be told do anything else with this data, in contrast to Garmin units.

Plenty of Garmin wearables function all-day stress tracking according to your center fee variability. This allows you to see if you find yourself essentially the most or least wired all through the day — an invaluable metric for many who realize (or do not realize) patterns of their temper. Garmin does be offering guided respiring workout routines on a couple of of its units, nevertheless it does not make the most of the center fee observe that will help you stick to alongside.

Then again, on more moderen Garmin units there is a exercise mode referred to as breathwork, and those don’t seem to be your usual stress-relief respiring workout routines, both. As soon as you choose breathwork, you can be requested to make a choice which form of breathwork you need to concentrate on: coherence, chill out and center of attention (lengthy and quick variations), or tranquility. From right here, your watch will stroll you via quite a lot of respiring patterns that will help you chill out or center of attention. I will be able to’t see myself the usage of all of them too steadily, however they are there when you’re wanting a psychological destroy all through the day.

garmin vivoactive 4 review workout screen breathwork elliptical

Each ecosystems supply their very own variations of menstrual cycle monitoring for women. Fitbit’s model is known as feminine well being monitoring, and lets in ladies to trace their classes, fertile home windows, ovulation days, and feminine well being signs. That is all made higher by means of the Fitbit app, which can be utilized to talk with different ladies about any problems they will have.

Garmin’s function is known as menstrual cycle monitoring and we could customers log length get started and finish dates, bodily and emotional signs, make private notes, and extra. Garmin makes it some extent to remind customers that this selection is for all sorts of customers, whether or not their cycle is common, abnormal, or if they are transitioning into menopause.

Each corporations supply some kind of on-device, guided exercises. Just a restricted choice of on-screen exercises are to be had out of the field at the Versa, Versa 2, and Ionic, however extra may also be added if you are a Fitbit Top rate subscriber (extra on that later).

Garmin’s more moderen watches (Venu, Vivoactive 4/4S) improve animated, on-device exercises. Aerobic, energy, yoga, and Pilates exercises are all to be had on-device, and extra are to be had to obtain via Garmin Attach.

Fitbit vs Garmin: Sensible options

garmin venu review spotify app music

Health merchandise don’t seem to be simply health merchandise any longer — maximum of them additionally double as smartwatches. On the very least, they’ve a couple of smartwatch options that make our lives a bit of more straightforward.

Each Garmin and Fitbit units improve smartphone notifications on Android and iOS, however simplest Android customers can respond to and delete messages from their wearables. The Fitbit Versa 2 even has a scaled-back model of Amazon Alexa baked in, which means that the watch helps voice replies and has the facility to go looking issues on the net. Garmin units do not include any type of voice assistant.

Maximum Garmin and Fitbit watches additionally improve onboard music storage, however Fitbit has one evident drawback: no offline Spotify improve. Garmin helps Spotify in addition to Amazon MusicDeezer, and iHeartRadio, whilst Fitbit simplest helps native track, Pandora, or Deezer.

Additionally learn: The best workout earbuds you can buy

A variety of apps will also be downloaded to Garmin and Fitbit units, together with Uber, Strava, and extra. Contactless cost improve is to be had on maximum Garmin and Fitbit units too, within the type of Garmin Pay and Fitbit Pay.

Fitbit vs Garmin: Apps

fitbit versa 2 review fitbit app google pixel 3

Your choice to make a choice Fitbit or Garmin will in all probability rely on which health product you need, however it’s a must to stay smartphone apps in thoughts, too. Finally, that is the place you can investigate cross-check efficiency stats, day-to-day and weekly process metrics, and extra.

The Fitbit app is essentially the most consumer pleasant choice of the two. When you open it up, you can be offered with a house display screen that is simple at the eyes and easy to navigate. Your day-to-day stats are proven on the best, and you’ll be able to scroll down to peer your contemporary workout and sleep. If you need to take a look at efficiency or sleep metrics over the years, simply click on at the class proper from the principle display screen and you can see your whole earlier process. This makes it simple to make use of for first-timers, as you do not wish to scroll via other tabs or menus to search out what you need.

The Garmin Connect app has stepped forward so much over the last 12 months, however it is nonetheless a bit of extra sophisticated. The primary display screen on Garmin Attach will show your day-to-day process metrics, and clicking on each and every one offers you additional information and your historical past. It is far more information-dense than Fitbit’s app, that could be a just right or unhealthy factor relying on what form of consumer you might be. I if truth be told like how a lot data Garmin’s app presentations on each and every display screen, however I have additionally been the usage of Garmin units for years, so I am used to it by means of now.

Fitbit’s app is one of the most efficient health apps round. Garmin’s is just right, however a bit of too information-dense for some.

On best of the already information-dense house display screen, Garmin Attach additionally has a slide-out menu at the facet that permits you to see process, well being, and function stats, in addition to customized exercises, insights, and extra. That is principally an overflow menu for issues that Garmin could not have compatibility within the backside tab.

Garmin’s app presentations extra post-workout news, whilst Fitbit’s turns out adore it’s geared extra in opposition to rookies or individuals who desire a easy evaluate in their day-to-day process. If you need the entire health metrics to be had, we would recommend going with Garmin. Then again, each ecosystems even have internet sites that show much more of your process metrics if you wish to have extra that what is supplied in both app.

Each apps function menus on the backside that permit you to briefly leap into your demanding situations, notifications, and extra. Garmin Attach includes a at hand calendar that permits you to leap again to any date you need to peer your process for that day. Fitbit’s app allows you to glance again at your process historical past too, however you wish to have to scroll again one day at a time. It is simply more straightforward to leap round in Garmin’s app.

garmin venu review garmin connect app on pixel 3

Garmin Attach will have a leg up at the calendar, however Fitbit knocks it out of the park with social options. Fitbit’s neighborhood tab allows you to hook up with different Fitbit house owners that experience an identical pursuits to you. You’ll touch upon different customers’ footage, sign up for teams, and extra. It is principally a complete social community within the Fitbit app, and it is superior.

Garmin’s app allows you to sign up for teams too, however it is not just about as social as Fitbit’s.

Fitbit additionally wins in relation to third-party app improve. Dozens of third-party smartphone apps paintings with Fitbit’s app — like MyFitnessPal, MapMyRun, Weight Watchers, and extra — so your whole Fitbit information will robotically sync together with your favourite health and fitness applications. I have additionally spotted third-party health apps on Fitbit’s ecosystem are normally higher high quality. Fitbit remains to be quite new to the smartwatch area, so there don’t seem to be a ton of watch apps to be had for the Versa, Versa 2, or Ionic but. The quantity has grown immensely since Fitbit first introduced its app retailer, which is a smart signal for the way forward for the ecosystem.

An excellent quantity of third-party apps also are to be had on Garmin’s watches and health trackers, which may also be discovered within the Garmin Connect IQ app (sure, there is a complete other smartphone app only for downloading third-party apps). 

3rd-party watch faces also are to be had on Garmin and Fitbit units. There are a ton to make a choice from, however each ecosystems supply a terrible looking out enjoy. Fitbit does not allow you to load up greater than one watch face at a time, so you wish to have to seek for a brand new one each and every time you need to switch it. It takes each ecosystems’ units a very long time to sync, too, so do not be expecting to make a choice an eye face and cargo it up instantly.

Top rate options

Fitbit has not too long ago switched up its industry style. It is now providing a subscription provider referred to as Fitbit Premium, which, for $9.99 a month or $79.99 a 12 months, will get you get entry to to guided exercise techniques, complex well being and health insights, complex sleep gear, and dynamic exercises according to your efficiency. 

You’ll join a unfastened trial of Fitbit Top rate on the hyperlink beneath.

Sign up for Fitbit Premium

Garmin provides a large number of this stuff free of charge. Garmin Trainer coaching plans, which come unfastened with the acquisition of many Garmin watches, assist you to teach for a 5K, 10Okay, or part marathon with the assistance of three skilled runners. It if truth be told helped me run my first half marathon!

Fitbit vs Garmin: Which ecosystem is best for you?

So, which ecosystem is best? The place will have to you spend your hard earned money? Sadly there is no definitive resolution to that. All of it will depend on what form of consumer you might be and what you wish to have out of a health gadget.

It is onerous to not steer extra informal customers — the oldsters who simply need a greater thought in their day-to-day process — in opposition to Fitbit. The app is more straightforward to grasp, Fitbit units are stellar health trackers, and for essentially the most phase they are extra trendy. However there are many choices in Fitbit’s lineup if you wish to cross kind of complex together with your health monitoring. The Ionic is there to your high-end GPS smartwatch wishes, whilst the Inspire HR is there in the event you simply desire a easy health tracker.

It is onerous to not steer extra informal customers in opposition to Fitbit, whilst other folks involved in extra complex options will need to take a look at Garmin’s lineup.

That isn’t to mention Garmin will have to be counted out for extra informal customers both. The Vivosmart 4 is a good entry-level tracker if you wish to have a Fitbit choice. Even though, Garmin in reality shines with its GPS watches. Critically, there is something in Garmin’s lineup for all sorts of complex customers. Plus, Garmin’s app offers you as a lot news — graphs, charts, you identify it — because it in all probability can after each and every exercise. If you wish to cross all-in on health monitoring and want the ones minute main points, we would recommend Garmin.

Then again, whichever ecosystem you select, we expect you can be simply superb — each Fitbit and Garmin be offering quite a lot of units, products and services, and apps that are meant to don’t have any downside suiting most of the people’s wishes.

Alright, now it is your flip — which ecosystem is your favourite?

Please wait..Loading ballot

Subsequent: How to get in shape with your fitness tracker in just 7 minutes… a day

Published by Marshmallow

Marshmallow Android is BT Ireland’s Head of Sales for Republic of Ireland domestic multi-site companies, indigenous MNCs and public sector accounts. He is responsible for the direction and control of all sales activity in the region. He has over 10 years management experience from high growth start-ups to more established businesses. He’s led teams in Ireland, India and China across various industries (ICT, On-Line Recruitment, Corporate Training and International Education).